Vertical, aquaculture
Dissolved oxygen alarms
Updated
A dissolved oxygen (DO) alarm should warn you while fish are still comfortable and act before they are stressed. For most farmed fish, extension guidance puts optimum health at 5 mg/L or more, distress at 2 to 4 mg/L and mortality usually below 2 mg/L. Salmonids need more, and tilapia tolerate much less, so the setpoints depend on the species, and the alarm should also open backup oxygen on its own.
What DO level should trigger an alarm?
Set two levels per tank or system: a warning that leaves time to investigate, and an action level that calls people and starts backup oxygen. Both sit above the stress range for the species. The published thresholds below are the starting point:
| Species or system | Published guidance | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Most farmed fish (general) | 5 mg/L or more for optimum health; distress at 2–4 mg/L; mortality usually below 2 mg/L; start emergency aeration below 4 mg/L | UF/IFAS FA27 |
| Warmwater recirculating systems | At least 60% of saturation, usually 5 ppm or more; more than 2 ppm in biofilter effluent | SRAC 452 |
| Trout in raceways | Reduce tank loading when outflow DO drops below 6 ppm | SRAC 222 |
| Tilapia | Survive dawn DO below 0.3 mg/L, but manage to keep DO above 1 mg/L; growth was not improved by keeping DO above 2.0–2.5 mg/L | SRAC 283 |
| Channel catfish ponds | Aeration usually starts at a critical level around 3–4 mg/L | Mississippi State Extension |
Note that 1 ppm and 1 mg/L are the same for DO in fresh water. Note also that the tilapia figures are survival and growth limits in ponds, not targets for a dense tank: in a RAS the biofilter needs oxygen too, and SRAC 452 says nitrifying bacteria become inefficient below 2 ppm.
A working pattern, to be tuned to your species and your own logged data:
- Warning: the low end of your normal operating range, for example 1 to 2 mg/L above the action level.
- Action: at or just above the published stress level for the species.
- Delay: a short time-on-condition (tens of seconds) so a single noisy reading does not page anyone, but not so long that a fast fall is missed.
- High DO alarm too, where pure oxygen is injected. SRAC 452 warns that poorly mixed supersaturated water can cause gas bubble disease, and fry are particularly sensitive.
Why percent saturation matters
Water holds less oxygen when it is warm. UF/IFAS gives saturation at about 11.9 mg/L at 45 °F and about 7.4 mg/L at 90 °F (FA27). A fixed 5 mg/L alarm is 42% of saturation in cold water and 68% in warm water. That is why SRAC 452 states its target both ways. If your controller can compute percent saturation from DO and temperature, an alarm on both is more robust across seasons. Salinity and altitude lower saturation further, so use a sensor or table that corrects for them.
When does DO fall?
- At night, in ponds and green water. Photosynthesis adds oxygen in daylight and respiration removes it at night; DO is lowest just before daybreak, when fish kills most often occur (UF/IFAS FA27). Mississippi State notes that nearly every catfish pond is below 2 mg/L at dawn in mid-summer.
- Around feeding. SRAC 452 advises close monitoring before and after feedings, and warns that near harvest size the oxygen demand can exceed the aeration system’s capacity.
- Within minutes after a pump or power failure in a dense RAS. SRAC 452’s example drops to 3 ppm in 16 minutes, or under 6 minutes at higher density. See Preventing a 3 a.m. fish kill.
Watch the fish as a cross-check. Gathering at the surface and crowding around aerators signal oxygen stress, but SRAC 452 notes that high CO2 and nitrite toxicity produce the same behaviour.
Which DO sensor type suits an alarm?
Three technologies are common (Sensorex):
| Type | How it works | For continuous alarms |
|---|---|---|
| Optical (luminescent) | Oxygen quenches a luminescent dye in the sensor cap; no oxygen is consumed | Needs no minimum water flow and has no electrolyte; responds more slowly than galvanic |
| Galvanic | Electrochemical cell that reduces oxygen; self-polarizing | Usable straight after calibration and responds 2–5 times faster than optical, but needs flow past the membrane (Sensorex quotes 2 in/s for its models) |
| Polarographic | Electrochemical cell with an applied voltage | Needs 5–15 minutes to polarize after power-up and consumes oxygen at the membrane |
For a probe that sits in a tank for months, an optical sensor’s independence from flow is the deciding property: a flow-dependent probe can read wrongly at exactly the moment a pump stops. Whatever the type:
- Calibrate on a schedule and log the date; a drifting probe is a silent failure.
- Alarm on sensor faults (no signal, out-of-range value, a reading that has not changed for hours), not only on low DO.
- Mount the probe where it can be reached for cleaning, as Ebeling advises (Global Seafood Alliance).
- In a critical system, use two probes or pair DO with flow and power alarms, so one bad sensor cannot hide a real event.
What should a low-DO alarm do?
Telling someone is not enough when oxygen can fall in minutes. Tie the action level to an automatic response:
- Open backup oxygen. At the Freshwater Institute, a relay changes state when DO is out of range, which triggers the dial-out alarm and opens a solenoid valve that sends backup oxygen to submerged diffusers while staff are on the way (Hatchery International).
- Make the valve open on power loss too. SRAC 452 recommends an oxygen tank on a solenoid valve that opens automatically during power failures.
- Start standby aeration or a standby pump if the cause may be a stopped blower or pump.
- Call people and escalate until someone acknowledges. See Alarm escalation by SMS and voice call.
- Alarm on the backup itself: low oxygen tank pressure, or a valve commanded open with no change in DO.
UF/IFAS adds a pond-specific step: measure DO at 5 to 6 p.m. and 8 to 10 p.m., and if the trend projects DO below 4 mg/L before 7 a.m., start emergency aeration before it happens (FA27). A logging controller can make that projection automatically and warn in the evening rather than at dawn.
Common mistakes
- One setpoint for all seasons, ignoring temperature.
- A probe in the tank but nothing downstream of it: no relay, no valve, no call.
- Alarm delays of several minutes copied from a slow pond setting into a dense RAS.
- No alarm for a dead or fouled sensor.
- A DO alarm that works, sent through a dialer that has no battery backup.
Sources
- Dissolved Oxygen for Fish Production, UF/IFAS Extension FA27 (Ruth Francis-Floyd), accessed 2026-11-19
- SRAC Publication No. 452, Recirculating Aquaculture Tank Production Systems: Management of Recirculating Systems (Masser, Rakocy, Losordo, March 1999 revision), accessed 2026-11-19
- SRAC Publication No. 222, Trout Farming: Carrying Capacity and Inventory Management (Jeffrey M. Hinshaw, July 2000 revision), accessed 2026-11-19
- SRAC Publication No. 283, Tilapia: Life History and Biology (Popma and Masser, March 1999), accessed 2026-11-19
- Catfish Water Quality, Mississippi State University Extension, accessed 2026-11-19
- Process control, monitoring options in intensive recirculation systems, Global Seafood Alliance (James M. Ebeling, 1 June 2003), accessed 2026-11-19
- Emergency response for RAS, Hatchery International (John Davidson, 25 April 2022), accessed 2026-11-19
- Selecting Among Dissolved Oxygen Measurement Methods, Sensorex, accessed 2026-11-19